IHeartJake.com was established by Ally in November of 2003 and was maintained by her for over a year. She was soon joined by Stephanie, who aided her in updating and taking care of the fansite. As time went by, Ally got busy with life and lost interest in maintaining the website. Stephanie continued to dedicate her time to the fansite for the next 7 years.
In July 2011, IHeartJake.com joined forces with Jake Gyllenhaal Online, another great fansite on Jake, owned and run by Connie. With the merge of IHJ and JGO, and the help of Connie, IHeartJake.com underwent many changes, including upgrading to WordPress.
Stephanie and Connie continue to run IHeartJake.com to date.